Back
Singing
With Southern Europe's Flavors
As
featured in the New York Times, By PATRICIA BROOKS
Published: May 19, 2002
IN recent years Sage has been a hot-button restaurant name.
But Rosemary and Sage in Old Saybrook has carried this a step
further. What next? Rosemary, Sage and Coriander?
Actually,
what makes this charming new arrival (ensconced in the former
premises of Cafe Routier, which has moved to Westbrook) so
appealing is not the name, fragrant and inviting as it is,
but the winning combination of food, cozy setting and welcoming,
upbeat staff.
Subtitled
''Mediterranean Grill and Wine Bar,'' Rosemary and Sage certainly
has that right. All the freshness and the kitchen's expertise
make a meal here sheer pleasure. All the palate-pleasing,
clear, unadulterated, salubrious flavors of southern Europe
sing loud and clear. An example is the simple tri-color salad,
a harvest of arugula, radicchio and endive, anointed with
balsamic vinaigrette, and topped with sheets of shaved parmigiana
cheese -- simple perfection.
What
makes this more than just another attractive Mediterranean-cum-Italian
restaurant is its originality. Stuffed oysters may not sound
special, but this version featured shells bursting with an
abundance of fresh crabmeat, spinach, bacon, mushrooms, green
and red peppers, and oysters, of course, lolling in a velvety
sauce that combined brandy with béarnaise insouciantly.
Superb!
Another
appetizer, tunnoli (cannoli shell filled with pan-seared tuna),
sounded tantalizing, but the supply was depleted that night.
Dismayed, my guest turned to ricco e povero. Disappointment
gave way to unmitigated delight at the huge bowl of savory
broad beans, wearing a banner of fresh basil and brimming
with shrimp, squid, scallops, mussels and red onions, in a
wispy citrus-spiked garlicky broth of a sauce.
Rosemary
and Sage's firecracker calamari crackled and snapped zestfully.
The lightly battered, fried squid were shrouded in a red sauce
as peppery as it looked -- made with plum tomatoes and tossed
with capers, onion, kalamata olives and hot cherry peppers.
Innovation surfaced also in Rachel's pollo -- chicken breast
stuffed with fresh spinach, feta cheese and pine nuts, wrapped
in bacon, baked, sliced into attractive cross sections and
served in a white wine sauce perfumed with sage. This delicious
entree was enhanced by fresh-whipped potatoes and al dente
asparagus.
My
first soft-shell crabs of spring will be hard to surpass.
Lightly wrapped in an herb-seasoned batter, sautéed
brown and served in a tangy sauce of lime, thyme and garlic,
they came with buttery spinach and roasted potatoes carved
into mushroom shapes (caps, stems and all), a conceit as tasty
as it was pretty. Portions are generous to a fault. Considering
all our dishes, the chewy bread with aromatic olive oil for
dipping and an amuse-bouche (a tidbit of mint-garlic-accented
eggplant salad on terrific house-made focaccia), we didn't
crave dessert.
But
duty called, so I ordered fallen chocolate cake, which, our
waitress explained, would ''take a few minutes as the chef
bakes everything to order.'' Our 10-minute wait -- while sipping
the last of our Robert Mondavi pinot noir (at $29 per bottle)
-- was worth it. The cake -- firm-textured outside, rich and
runny bitter chocolate within -- came with vanilla ice cream
studded with chocolate-covered almonds. Friends tried the
apple tart (also excellent) and an unusual, finely grained
semolina cake, moist from a fruit sauce and crested with slices
of caramelized bananas.
Astonished
by the quality and creativity in every dish, there was still
one agreeable surprise left -- our bill: $72 for two, before
tax, tip and drinks. A well-chosen wine list, which roams
the viniculture map, begins at $21.
Off
Exit 66 on I-95, Rosemary and Sage is already worth a special
trip. Don't expect fancy flourishes or trendy décor.
What you'll find, if my visits are a barometer, is delicious,
top-quality food, prepared with skill and imagination. As
the old song goes, ''who could ask for anything more?''
Rosemary
and Sage
1080 Boston Post Road, Old Saybrook
(860)388-1166
Excellent
ATMOSPHERE
A charming, tiny dining room in salmon hues, with cafe shutters
and Thonet chairs.
NOISE LEVEL Animated when crowded, but helped by carpeting
and well-spaced tables.
SERVICE Well-trained and helpful.
RECOMMENDED DISHES Stuffed oysters, tri-color salad, ricco
e povero, penne al mondo vecchio, gnocchi, Rachel's pollo,
soft shell crab, carne d'agnello in crosta di pane, fallen
chocolate cake, semolina cake, apple tart.
PRICE RANGE Lunch entrees, $10-$14; Dinner entrees, $15-$23.
CREDIT CARDS Most major cards accepted.
HOURS Lunch: 11:30 A.M. - 2 P.M. Monday through Friday; Dinner:
5 P.M. - 9:30 P.M. Monday through Thursday, 5 P.M.- 10:30
P.M. Friday and Saturday. Closed Sunday.
RESERVATIONS Accepted.
WHEELCHAIR ACCESSIBILITY street level to dining level, restrooms
on same level.